Sister of Charity Given Ultimatum Over Support of WOC
Background
After 40 years in the Archdiocese of Cincinnati, Sister of Charity Louise Akers
has been told by Archbishop Daniel E. Pilarczyk to publicly disassociate
herself from the issue of women's ordination if she wishes to continue making any
presentations or teaching for credit in any archdiocesan-related institutions.
On August 10, 2009, Archbishop Pilarczyk met with S. Louise and outlined the
following requirements: First, that she remove her name from our Women's
Ordination Conference website. Secondly, that she publicly rescind her
long-held stance supporting the ordination of women. As a matter of conscience,
Sister Louise will not renounce her support for women's equality in the
church.
Sister Louise currently serves on WOC's National Antiracism Team.
The following is a statement from Erin Saiz Hanna,
Executive Director of the Women's Ordination Conference.
"The Women's Ordination Conference supports Sister Louise Akers in her life and
ministry. Sister Louise, a Sister of Charity and advocate for peace,
antiracism and interreligious relations, has dedicated her life in service to
social justice. We believe asking Sister Louise to go against her own
conscience and renounce her belief in women's full equality in the Church, which
includes women's ordination, is a prime example of the way women are often
wrongly treated by the hierarchy in the Roman Catholic Church.
We ask that she be reinstated into her teaching position with
archdiocesan-related institutions in a timely manner, and that any
presentations given by Sister Louise will qualify for full credit.
We oppose the limitations set by Archbishop Daniel E. Pilarczyk. His
requirements imposed on Sister Louise will not extinguish the widespread call
for women's equality nor intimidate women into accepting marginal status within
the Church.
The Vatican's stance on ordination is based on arguments that have been refuted
time and again. In 1976, the Vatican's own Pontifical Biblical Commission
determined that there is no scriptural reason to prohibit women's ordination.
However, the Vatican ignored this finding and in 1994, Pope John Paul II
officially forbade discussion of women's ordination. People have been
fired from their jobs in Catholic institutions simply for discussing the issue,
and this recent development with Sister Louise is one more unfortunate example
in an all-too-familiar pattern of the misuse of Church discipline as a way of
dealing with differences and dissent.
Sister Louise has the support of over 63% of U.S. Catholics who support women's
ordination. WOC activists will continue to work tirelessly until the hearts of
the hierarchy, including Archbishop Pilarczyk, are opened and steps are taken
to include women as full and equal partners, including ordained ministries.
Only then will the Roman Catholic Church be better able to provide a model and
a vision for a world in great need of justice, equality and peace. "